How do you understand our democratic process functions? Maybe similar to this. The public votes for MPs. They legislate on bills. If a majority is obtained, the bills are enacted as law. The law are enforced by the courts. Simple as that. However, that used to be how it operated in the past. Those days are over.
The Advent of Shadow Courts
Nowadays, international firms, along with the oligarchs who own them, are able to litigate against nation states for the laws they pass, at offshore tribunals made up of commercial attorneys. The cases are held away from public scrutiny. In contrast to domestic courts, these panels grant no opportunity to appeal or oversight by judges. Ordinary citizens cannot take a case to them, nor can our government, or even businesses based in this country. The door is open only to corporations registered abroad.
If a tribunal finds that a government measure might diminish the corporation’s projected profits, it has the power to grant compensation of hundreds of millions, potentially billions.
This compensation represent not actual losses but compensation the tribunal officials determine the company might otherwise have made. The government may have to drop the legislation. It becomes deterred from passing future laws of a similar nature, worried about incurring a lawsuit.
A Process Running Rampant
Record numbers of disputes are being initiated, as firms take cues from each other, and hedge funds bankroll lawsuits in exchange for a share of the awards. The result? Democratic sovereignty and democracy are turning into unaffordable.
The process is referred to as “investor-state dispute settlement” (ISDS). The explanation it can trump domestic law and the choices enacted by elected bodies is that this clause has been incorporated – without public consent, and typically amid an atmosphere of profound opacity – within international trade agreements.
A Real-World Instance: The Cumbrian Coalmine
A year ago, activists won a great victory at the high court. The judge ruled that plans to excavate the first major coal mine in the UK for 30 years, in northwest England, had been unlawfully approved by the previous government, which had endorsed the extraordinary assertion that the mine would have had no impact on climate commitments. The incoming administration later cancelled the consent the previous administration had issued. Currently, this legal outcome could be compromised by an secret arbitration panel reporting to no one but the entities filing the suit.
In August, a firm whose ultimate owners are based in the offshore financial centre initiated proceedings challenging the UK government. Last week a arbitration panel in the US capital was convened to adjudicate on it.
This firm is suing the UK for the profits it might have made if the mine had been allowed to go ahead. The public has little idea how much this could amount to. Which individual is serving as its counsel against the UK administration? An elected representative, and previous senior legal advisor in the previous government, that great patriot the MP. The administration passes a law, the domestic court upholds it, then a international entity challenges it through an secretive private court, and a elected official works for its behalf.
The Russian Case
Simultaneously that the panel on the coal mine dispute was convened, information emerged from a ministerial statement that the UK is subject to further litigation under ISDS by a wealthy Russian individual, an oligarch. Details are nothing of the case so far, but it is highly possible that he’ll use the arbitration process to contest the restrictions the UK levied against him subsequent to the invasion of Ukraine. He has previously initiated proceedings against a small nation on these grounds, claiming a colossal sum: an amount representing half government’s yearly budget. Among the legal team on his side? the wife of a former prime minister, married to the former British prime minister.
Legal experts believe that the EU’s hesitation in leveraging immobilised oligarchs' funds as collateral for its loan to Ukraine stems from Belgium’s fear that it could be sued in the secret arbitration panels, under a investment pact. This unprecedented, unaccountable authority over democratic administrations may be obstructing the money Ukraine urgently requires.
Empty Promises and Growing Costs
The public was told that these events were not possible. In 2014, a government leader, advocating for the most significant and hazardous of all investment pacts, declared: “The UK has signed trade agreement after trade deal and there has never been a case in the past.” An expert on this topic accused campaigners of “alarmism … in reality, ISDS has little impact on the UK much”. The prevailing narrative was crafted to be that exclusively weaker states should be concerned by ISDS claims. Predictions that “when companies start to realise the power bestowed upon them, they will turn their attention from the vulnerable countries to the strong ones” were met with general mockery.
That warning has now materialised. Recently, fossil fuel and extraction companies have lodged a unprecedented number of suits against nations both wealthy and developing, opposing – similar to the Whitehaven project – official measures to halt environmental catastrophe. Corporations have so far won one hundred and fourteen billion dollars through ISDS, of which fossil fuel companies have been awarded $84bn. That is equivalent to the combined GDP